|
Debra Lynn Dadd
stainless steel food containersQUESTION: I would like to buy my son a stainless steel food container (preferally insulated) to use for packing school lunches. With so many brands, I'm not sure which to buy. Any suggestions? I'm looking for something bigger than the soup containers that I have been seeing in the stores. I want something that I can pack a mini-meal. I bought him a stainless steel water bottle (Thermos brand). When I was looking at them in the store I noticed a metal smell inside when opening them- Not sure if that will go away after washing. I 'm trying to get away from plastic and do not want to pack his lunch in glass- in case he drops it. Is stainless steel the next best alternative after glass? I don't want any metals leaching into his food!!! POSTED BY STACY D :: :: 123 RIDGECREST DRIVE :: PENNSYLVANIA USA :: 08/20/2009 2:34 PM DEBRA'S ANSWER:
The metal smell doesn't go away. Metals might leach from stainless steel containers more or less, depending on the acidity of the food.
Personally, after glass, I would choose a polyethylene plastic container over a stainless steel container. Polyethylene is very stable and does not smell or leach in my experience.
I no longer use stainless steel anything. Debra :-)
COMMENTS: Are you sure it's not polypropylene instead of polyethylene? I thought that polyethylene was one of the one's to avoid.
COMMENT FROM DEBRA:
I'm totally certain I meant polyethylene. :-)
POSTED BY STACYD :: :: 123 RIDGECREST DRIVE :: PENNSYLVANIA USA :: 08/24/2009 4:49 PM
Really? Stainless steel is unsafe too!
Ugh! This is so disappointing to me.
I moved to stainless steel water bottles and thermoses to get away from plastic as well.
And they are not cheap - the water bottles are $15-$20 a piece! Plus they are great at keeping the water cold.
So plastic is safer than stainless steel?
This is so new to me..could someone explain to me why. And why if metal can leak onto foods, are the stainless steel items so popular and being advertised as so safe?
Thanks!
A concerned mom!
COMMENT FROM DEBRA:
"Plastic" is not safer than stainless steel. Polyethylene plastic is safer than stainless steel. Polyethylene leaches nothing and stainless steel leaches heavy metals.
POSTED BY CHARLENE GORMLEY :: MASSACHUSETTS USA :: 08/24/2009 5:07 PM
My son does use glass for lunch with a plastic lid. What I do is pad his cloth lunchbag with a folded tea towel in the bottom. In the past two years he has broken it just once and he was only 4 and 5 years old. POSTED BY LINDA :: ARKANSAS USA :: 08/31/2009 1:03 PM
Debra -
Re your statement "I no longer use stainless steel anything" -- What about flatware? I love the design of my flatware and it's stainless steel, but I've had concerns for some time it might be leaching nickel or other metals. (And is there a swab that tests for all metals, not just specific ones?)
Thanks!
COMMENT FROM DEBRA:
I use silverplate. But I need to do more research on that too...I may end up with chopsticks!
POSTED BY L.A. :: CALIFORNIA USA :: 08/31/2009 3:41 PM
Regarding the leaching of stainless steel, is this true only of foods that are acidic?
When you say you no longer use any stainless steel, how about for carrying water?
I'm trying to not contribute to plastic consumption safe or unsafe because it doesn't break down. So I'm torn about purchasing stainless steel water bottles for my children's lunch boxes. If you have a link showing how stainless steel leaches, I'd love to read it. When I searched for stainless steel leaching, I couldn't find any supporting information that it leached heavy metals as long as the metal wasn't being heated.
Thank you so much for your help.
COMMENT FROM DEBRA:
I carry my water in glass bottles.
Many years ago I read a study done by Rodale Press in which they distilled water in a stainless steel distiller and found metals in the distilled water that were not there before the water went into the distiller. I haven't found that study on the Internet. I intend to do more research on this and come up with some definitive studies.
POSTED BY JH :: CALIFORNIA USA :: 08/31/2009 4:00 PM
Charlene when in doubt I use common sense: I have being diagnosed with mercury & lead poisoning and extremely high levels of aluminum, cadmium & gadolinium. I've learned to use my mind differently now. I never go by what "they" say. So I asked myself "how do I know stainless steel is safe?" I mean after all it is an alloy of metals, a red flag should go off right there. A google search indicates that SS leaches chromium and nickel. I do not trust plastics of any kind. I have a hard time believing that any plastic could be safe but that's me: I have severe plastic sensitivity and intolerance and if it looks like a duck... I have replaced all metal utensils by unvarnished wood ones. I'm just trying to get better, not trying to avoid some future illness but dealing with present is bad enough. POSTED BY CHRIS :: CALIFORNIA USA :: 08/31/2009 5:24 PM
Debra, I can't believe I didn't think of chopsticks! Great idea! I actually was thinking of trying bambooware - it's supposed to be "disposable" but apparently is washable for multiple uses (hopefully many uses - it's not cheap like plastic!).
I have some white porcelain Japanese soup spoons that could supplement the chopsticks and such. Maybe I should LeadCheck them? I still see them in Asian import stores, and they're very inexpensive, and nice to use!
COMMENT FROM DEBRA:
Would you Lead Check the soup spoons? I don't have one here to check. And please report back. :-)
POSTED BY L.A. :: CALIFORNIA USA :: 09/07/2009 1:48 PM
Embarrassed to say I've never lead-checked anything in my kitchen - one of those things I've got to get to! I should buy a bunch of the swabs, since my china and cooking utensils are a collection of this's and thats!
But I bought my porcelain (Chinese-restaurant-style) spoons many years ago, and don't even know whether they were made in China or Japan (bought them in a Japanese import store, but for quite a while most of their stock became increasingly imported from China). I expect the glazes would vary with the manufacturer, even though they're white...
Whenever I get to checking them, I'll certainly let you know, though results may differ from what's being sold now. Afraid of what I may find with all my kitchen items, including those I love using! POSTED BY L.A. :: CALIFORNIA USA :: 09/08/2009 2:47 AM
I also have a strong reaction to plastic and am looking for a replacement for my garbage bags. Any ideas from Chris about dealing with the plastic sensitivities? Thanks POSTED BY NOEL :: CALIFORNIA USA :: 09/09/2009 3:16 AM
Would it be safe to use SS baking sheets as long as they are lined with parchment paper or some form of non toxic liner? Are toxins released in the air when SS is heated or just when in contact with food?
Thanks!
COMMENT FROM DEBRA:
Just in contact with food. I use aluminum/steel baking sheets with parchment or silicone liners.
POSTED BY TEXASCOOK :: TEXAS USA :: 10/12/2009 2:38 PM
Aluminum is much more reactive than stainless or plain steel. A major component of stainlesss is nickel which is also used in heart valves because it is non-reactive to bodily processes. If stainless is undesirable, there is some titanium cookware available which is also non-reactive enough that it is used for various implants and bone repair applications.
POSTED BY BD :: NEW HAMPSHIRE USA :: 10/13/2009 4:40 PM :: POST YOUR COMMENT
Debra's List
~
100s of links
to 1000s of nontoxic, natural & earthwise
products
Debra's Free Newsletters
~
website
update, natural sweetener recipes, words of
wisdom
Debra's
Bookstore
~ recommended reading on health and the
environment
MCS
Recovery ~ resources for recovery
from multiple chemical sensitivities
Sweet Savvy
~ how to choose and use natural sweetners (lots of
recipes)
Talk With
Debra
~
call for a personal consultation (fee)
Copyright ©2004-2007 Debra Lynn Dadd - all rights reserved.
|
|
|